Jeremy Bentham

第9章

OurforeignpolicyduringthecenturyWasinthelongrunchieflydeterminedbytheinterestsofourtrade,howevermuchthetrademightattimesbehamperedbyill-conceivedregulations。ItisremarkablethatAdamSmith(3*)arguesthat,althoughthecapitalistisacuterthatthecountry-gentleman,hisacutenessischieflydisplayedbyknowinghisowninterestsbetter。Thoseinterests,hethinks,donotcoincidesomuchastheinterestsofthecountry-gentlemanwiththegeneralinterestsofthecountry。Consequentlythecountry-gentleman,thoughlessintelligent,ismorelikelytofavouranationalandliberalpolicy。Themerchant,infact,wasnotafree-traderbecausehehadreadAdamSmithorconsciouslyadoptedSmith’sprinciples,butbecauseorinsofarasparticularrestrictionsinterferedwithhim。ArthurYoungcomplainsbitterlyofthemanufacturerswhosupportedtheprohibitiontoexportEnglishwool,andsoprotectedtheirownclassattheexpenseofagriculturists。

Wedgwood,thoughagoodliberalandasupporterofPitt’sFrenchtreatyin1786,joinedinprotestingagainsttheproposalforfree-tradewithIreland。

TheIrish,hethought,mightrivalhispotteries。Thus,thoughasamatteroffactthegrowingclassofmanufacturersandmerchantswereinclinedinthemaintoliberalprinciples,itwaslessfromadhesiontoanygeneraldoctrinethanfromthefactthattheexistingrestrictionsandprejudicesgenerallyconflictedwiththeirplaininterests。

Anothercharacteristicisremarkable。Thoughthegrowthofmanufacturesandcommercemeantthegrowthofgreattowns,itdidnotmeanthegrowthofmunicipalinstitutions。Onthecontrary,asIshallpresentlyhavetonotice,themunicipalitiesweresinkingtotheirlowestebb。Manufactures,inthefirstinstance,spreadalongthestreamsintocountrydistricts:andtothegreatmanufacturer,workingforhisownhand,hisneighbourswerecompetitorsasmuchasallies。Thegreattowns,however,whichweregrowingup,showedthegeneraltendenciesoftheclass。Theywerecentresnotonlyofmanufacturingbutofintellectualprogress。ThepopulationofBirmingham,containingthefamousSohoworksofBoultonandWatt,hadincreasedbetween1740and1780from24,000to74,000inhabitants。Watt’spartnerBoultonstartedthe’LunarSociety’atBirmingham。(4*)ItsmostprominentmemberwasErasmusDarwin,famousthenforpoetrywhichischieflyrememberedbytheparodyintheAnti-Jacobin;andnowmorefamousastheadvocateofatheoryofevolutioneclipsedbytheteachingofhismorefamousgrandson,and,inanycase,amanofremarkableintellectualpower。AmongthosewhojoinedintheproceedingswasEdgeworth,whoin1768wasspeculatinguponmovingcarriagesbysteam,andThomasDay,whoseSandfordandMertonhelpedtospreadinEnglandtheeducationaltheoriesofRousseau。Priestley,whosettledatBirminghamin1780,becameamember,andwashelpedinhisinvestigationsbyWatt’scounselsandWedgwood’specuniaryhelp。AmongoccasionalvisitorswereSmeaton,SirJosephBanks,Solander,andHerschelofscientificcelebrity;whiletheliterarymagnate,DrParr,wholivedbetweenWarwickandBirmingham,occasionallyjoinedthecircle。Wedgwood,thoughtoofarofftobeamember,wasintimatewithDarwinandassociatedinvariousenterpriseswithBoulton。Wedgwood’scongenialpartner,ThomasBentley(1731-1780),hadbeeninbusinessatManchesterandatLiverpool。HehadtakenpartinfoundingtheWarrington’Academy,’

thedissentingseminary(afterwardsmovedtoManchester)ofwhichPriestleywastutor(1761-1767),andhadlectureduponartattheacademyfoundedatLiverpoolin1773。AnothermemberoftheacademywasWilliamRoscoe(1753-1831),whoseliterarytastewasshownbyhislivesofLorenzodeMediciandLeoX,andwhodistinguishedhimselfbyopposingtheslavetrade,thentheinfamyofhisnativetown。AlliedwithhiminthismovementwereWilliamRathboneandJamesCurrie(1756-1805)thebiographerofBurns,afriendofDarwinandanintelligentphysician。AtManchesterThomasPerceval(1740-1804)foundedthe’LiteraryandPhilosophicalSociety,in1780。HewasapupiloftheWarringtonAcademy,whichheafterwardsjoinedonremovingtoManchester,andheformedtheschemeafterwardsrealisedbyOwensCollege。Hewasanearlyadvocateofsanitarymeasuresandfactorylegislation,andamanofscientificreputation。

Othermembersofthesocietywere:JohnFerriar(1761-1815),bestknownbyhisIllustrationsofSterne,butalsoamanofliteraryandscientificreputation;

thegreatchemist,JohnDalton(1766-1844),whocontributedmanypaperstoitstransactions;and,forashorttime,theSocialistRobertOwen,thenarisingmanufacturer。AtNorwich,thenimportantasamanufacturingcentre,wasasimilarcircle。WilliamTaylor,aneminentUnitariandivine,whodiedattheWarringtonAcademyin1761,hadlivedatNorwich。OneofhisdaughtersmarriedDavidMartineauandbecamethemotherofHarrietMartineau,whohasdescribedtheNorwichofherearlyyears。JohnTaylor,grandsonofWilliam,wasfatherofMrsAustin,wifeofthejurist。Hewasamanofliterarytastes,andhiswifewasknownastheMadameRolandofNorwich。MrsOpie(1765-1853)

wasdaughterofJamesAlderson,aphysicianofNorwich,andpassedmostofherlifethere。WilliamTaylor(1761-1836),anotherNorwichmanufacturer,wasamongtheearliestEnglishstudentsofGermanliterature。Norwichhadafterwardstheuniquedistinctionofbeingthehomeofaprovincialschoolofartists。JohnCrome(1788-1821),sonofapoorweaver,andJohnSellCotman(1782-1842)wereitsleaders;theyformedakindofprovincialacademy,andexhibitedpictureswhichhavebeenmoreappreciatedsincetheirdeath。AtBristol,towardstheendofthecentury,weresimilarindicationsofintellectualactivity。ColeridgeandSoutheyfoundthereasocietyreadytolistentotheirearlylectures,andbothadmiredThomasBeddoes(1760-1808),aphysician,achemist,astudentofGerman,animitatorofDarwininpoetry,andanassailantofPittinpamphlets。HehadmarriedoneofEdgeworth’sdaughters。WiththehelpandadviceofWedgwoodandWatt,hefoundedthe’PneumaticInstitute’

atCliftonin1798,andobtainedthehelpofHumphryDavy,whotheremadesomeofhisfirstdiscoveries。DavywassoontransportedtotheRoyalInstitution,foundedatthesuggestionofCountRumfordin1799,whichrepresentedthegrowthofapopularinterestinthescientificdiscoveries。

Thegeneraltoneoftheselittlesocietiesrepresents,ofcourse,thetendencyoftheupperstratumoftheindustrialclasses。Intheirowneyestheynaturallyrepresentedtheprogressiveelementofsociety。TheywereWhigs——for’radicalism’wasnotyetinvented——butWhigsoftheleftwing;

acceptingthearistocraticprecedency,butlookingaskanceatthearistocraticprejudices。Theywererationalists,too,inprinciple,butagainwithinlimits:

openlyavowingthedoctrineswhichintheEstablishedchurchhadstilltobeshelteredbyostensibleconformitytothetraditionaldogmas。ManyofthemprofessedtheUnitarianismtowhichtheolddissentingbodiesinclined。

’Unitarianism,’saidshrewdoldErasmusDarwin,’isafeather-bedforadyingChristian。’ButatpresentsuchmenasPriestleyandPricewereonlysofarontheroadtoathoroughrationalismastodenouncethecorruptionsofChristianity,astheydenouncedabusesinpolitics,withoutanticipatingarevolutionarychangeinchurchandstate。Priestley,forexample,combined’materialism’

and’determinism’withChristianityandabeliefinmiracles,andcontrovertedHorsleyupononesideandPaineontheother。

II。THEAGRICULTURISTS

Thegeneralspiritrepresentedbysuchmovementswasbynomeansconfinedtothecommercialormanufacturingclasses;anditsmostcharacteristicembodimentistobefoundinthewritingsofaleadingagriculturist。

ArthurYoung,(5*)bornin1741,wasthesonofaclergyman,whohadalsoasmallancestralpropertyatBradfield,nearBurySt。Edmunds。Accidentsledtohisbecomingafarmeratanearlyage。Heshowedmorezealthandiscretion,andaftertryingthreethousandexperimentsonhisfarm,hewasgladtopay£;100toanothertenanttotakehisfarmoffhishands。Thisexperienceasapracticalagriculturist,farfromdiscouraginghim,qualifiedhiminhisownopiniontospeakwithauthority,andhebecameadevotedmissionaryofthegospelofagriculturalimprovement。Theenthusiasmwithwhichheadmiredmoresuccessfullabourersinthecause,andtheindignationwithwhichheregardsthesluggishandretrograde,arecharming。Hiskindliness,hiskeeninterestintheprosperityofallmen,richorpoor,hisardentbeliefinprogress,combinedwithhisquicknessofobservation,giveacharmtothewritingswhichembodyhisexperience。ToursinEnglandandatemporaryland-agencyinIrelandsuppliedhimwithmaterialsforbookswhichmadehimknownbothinEnglandandontheContinent。In1779hereturnedtoBradfield,wherehesoonafterwardscameintopossessionofhispaternalestate,whichbecamehispermanenthome。In1784hetriedtoextendhispropagandabybringingouttheAnnalsofAgriculture——amonthlypublication,ofwhichforty-fivehalf-yearlyvolumesappeared。Hehadmanyablecontributorsandhimselfwrotemanyinterestingarticles,butthepecuniaryresultsweremainlynegative。

In1791hiscirculationwasonly350copies。(6*)MeanwhilehisacquaintancewiththeducdeLiancourtledtotoursinFrancefrom1788to1790。HisTravelsinFrance,firstpublishedin1792,hasbecomeaclassic。In1793YoungwasmadesecretarytotheBoardofAgriculture,ofwhichIshallspeakpresently。

HebecameknowninLondonsocietyaswellasinagriculturalcircles。Hewasahandsomeandattractiveman,acharmingcompanion,andwidelyrecognisedasanagriculturalauthority。TheempressofRussiasenthimasnuff-box;

’FarmerGeorge’presentedamerinoram;hewaselectedmemberoflearnedsocieties;hevisitedBurkeatBeaconsfield,PittatHolmwood,andwasafriendofWilberforceandofJeremyBentham。

Younghadmanydomestictroubles。Hismarriagewasnotcongenial;thelossofatenderlyloveddaughterin1797permanentlysaddenedhim;hebecameblind,andinhislateryearssoughtcomfortinreligiousmeditationandinpreachingtohispoorerneighbours。Hedied20thApril1820。Heleftbehindhimagigantichistoryofagriculture,fillingtenfoliovolumesofmanuscript,which,thoughreducedtosixbyanenthusiasticdiscipleafterhisdeath,haveneverfoundtheirwaytopublication。

TheTravelsinFrance,Young’sbestbook,owesonemerittotheadviceofajudiciousfriend,whoremarkedthattheprevioustourshadsufferedfromtheabsenceofthepersonaldetailswhichinterestthecommonreader。

TheinsertionofthesemakesYoung’saccountofhisFrenchtoursoneofthemostcharmingaswellasmostinstructivebooksofthekind。Itgivesthevividimpressionmadeuponakeenandkindlyobserverinalltheirfreshness。

Hesensiblyretainedtheexpressionsofopinionmadeatthetime。’Imayremarkatpresent,’hesays,(7*)’thatalthoughIwastotallymistakeninmyprediction,yet,onarevision,IthinkIwasrightinit。’Itwasright,hemeans,uponthedatathenknowntohim,andheleavestheunfulfilledpredictionasitwas。Thebookisfrequentlycitedinjustificationoftherevolution,anditmaybefairlyurgedthathisauthorityisofthemoreweight,becausehedoesnotstartfromanysympathywithrevolutionaryprinciples。

YoungwasinPariswhentheoathwastakenatthetennis-court;andmakeshisreflectionsuponthebeautyoftheBritishConstitution,andthefollyofvisionaryreforms,inaspiritwhichmighthavesatisfiedBurke。Hewasthereforenotaltogetherinconsistentwhen,aftertheoutrages,hecondemnedtherevolution,howevermuchthefactswhichhedescribesmaytendtoexplaintheinevitablenessofthecatastrophe。Atanyrate,hisviewsareworthnoticebytheindicationswhichtheygiveofthementalattituDeofatypicalEnglishobserver。

字体大小
背景颜色