METAPHYSICS

第41章

Sincetherewerethreekindsofsubstance,twoofthemphysical

andoneunmovable,regardingthelatterwemustassertthatitis

necessarythatthereshouldbeaneternalunmovablesubstance。For

substancesarethefirstofexistingthings,andiftheyareall

destructible,allthingsaredestructible。Butitisimpossiblethat

movementshouldeitherhavecomeintobeingorceasetobe(forit

mustalwayshaveexisted),orthattimeshould。Fortherecouldnotbe

abeforeandanafteriftimedidnotexist。Movementalsois

continuous,then,inthesenseinwhichtimeis;fortimeiseither

thesamethingasmovementoranattributeofmovement。Andthereis

nocontinuousmovementexceptmovementinplace,andofthisonlythat

whichiscirculariscontinuous。

Butifthereissomethingwhichiscapableofmovingthingsor

actingonthem,butisnotactuallydoingso,therewillnot

necessarilybemovement;forthatwhichhasapotencyneednot

exerciseit。Nothing,then,isgainedevenifwesupposeeternal

substances,asthebelieversintheFormsdo,unlessthereistobein

themsomeprinciplewhichcancausechange;nay,eventhisisnot

enough,norisanothersubstancebesidestheFormsenough;forifit

isnottoact,therewillbenomovement。Furtherevenifitacts,

thiswillnotbeenough,ifitsessenceispotency;fortherewillnot

beeternalmovement,sincethatwhichispotentiallymaypossibly

notbe。Theremust,then,besuchaprinciple,whoseveryessenceis

actuality。Further,then,thesesubstancesmustbewithoutmatter;for

theymustbeeternal,ifanythingiseternal。Thereforetheymustbe

actuality。

Yetthereisadifficulty;foritisthoughtthateverything

thatactsisabletoact,butthatnoteverythingthatisableto

actacts,sothatthepotencyisprior。Butifthisisso,nothing

thatisneedbe;foritispossibleforallthingstobecapableof

existingbutnotyettoexist。

Yetifwefollowthetheologianswhogeneratetheworldfrom

night,orthenaturalphilosopherswhosaythat’allthingswere

together’,thesameimpossibleresultensues。Forhowwilltherebe

movement,ifthereisnoactuallyexistingcause?Woodwillsurelynot

moveitself-thecarpenter’sartmustactonit;norwillthemenstrual

bloodnortheearthsetthemselvesinmotion,buttheseedsmustact

ontheearthandthesemenonthemenstrualblood。

Thisiswhysomesupposeeternalactuality-e。g。Leucippusand

Plato;fortheysaythereisalwaysmovement。Butwhyandwhatthis

movementistheydosay,nor,iftheworldmovesinthiswayor

that,dotheytellusthecauseofitsdoingso。Nownothingis

movedatrandom,buttheremustalwaysbesomethingpresenttomove

it;e。g。asamatteroffactathingmovesinonewaybynature,and

inanotherbyforceorthroughtheinfluenceofreasonorsomething

else。(Further,whatsortofmovementisprimary?Thismakesavast

difference。)ButagainforPlato,atleast,itisnotpermissibleto

nameherethatwhichhesometimessupposestobethesourceof

movement-thatwhichmovesitself;forthesoulislater,andcoeval

withtheheavens,accordingtohisaccount。Tosupposepotencyprior

toactuality,then,isinasenseright,andinasensenot;andwe

havespecifiedthesesenses。Thatactualityisprioristestifiedby

Anaxagoras(forhis’reason’isactuality)andbyEmpedoclesinhis

doctrineofloveandstrife,andbythosewhosaythatthereisalways

movement,e。g。Leucippus。Thereforechaosornightdidnotexistfor

aninfinitetime,butthesamethingshavealwaysexisted(either

passingthroughacycleofchangesorobeyingsomeotherlaw),since

actualityispriortopotency。If,then,thereisaconstantcycle,

somethingmustalwaysremain,actinginthesameway。Andifthere

istobegenerationanddestruction,theremustbesomethingelse

whichisalwaysactingindifferentways。Thismust,then,actin

onewayinvirtueofitself,andinanotherinvirtueofsomething

else-eitherofathirdagent,therefore,orofthefirst。Nowit

mustbeinvirtueofthefirst。Forotherwisethisagaincausesthe

motionbothofthesecondagentandofthethird。Thereforeitis

bettertosay’thefirst’。Foritwasthecauseofeternaluniformity;

andsomethingelseisthecauseofvariety,andevidentlyboth

togetherarethecauseofeternalvariety。This,acc

这是VIP章节,可购买本章或开通会员后阅读
开通会员
字体大小
背景颜色