METAPHYSICS

第36章

Afurtherdifficultyisraisedbythefactthatallknowledgeis

ofuniversalsandofthe’such’,butsubstanceisnotauniversal,but

israthera’this’-aseparablething,sothatifthereisknowledge

aboutthefirstprinciples,thequestionarises,howarewetosuppose

thefirstprincipletobesubstance?

Further,isthereanythingapartfromtheconcretething(bywhich

Imeanthematterandthatwhichisjoinedwithit),ornot?Ifnot,

wearemetbytheobjectionthatallthingsthatareinmatterare

perishable。Butifthereissomething,itmustbetheformorshape。

Nowitishardtodetermineinwhichcasesthisexistsapartandin

whichitdoesnot;forinsomecasestheformisevidentlynot

separable,e。g。inthecaseofahouse。

Further,aretheprinciplesthesameinkindorinnumber?Ifthey

areoneinnumber,allthingswillbethesame。

Sincethescienceofthephilosophertreatsofbeingquabeing

universallyandnotinrespectofapartofit,and’being’hasmany

sensesandisnotusedinoneonly,itfollowsthatifthewordis

usedequivocallyandinvirtueofnothingcommontoitsvarious

uses,beingdoesnotfallunderonescience(forthemeaningsofan

equivocaltermdonotformonegenus);butifthewordisusedin

virtueofsomethingcommon,beingwillfallunderonescience。The

termseemstobeusedinthewaywehavementioned,like’medical’and

’healthy’。Foreachofthesealsoweuseinmanysenses。Termsare

usedinthiswaybyvirtueofsomekindofreference,intheone

casetomedicalscience,intheothertohealth,inothersto

somethingelse,butineachcasetooneidenticalconcept。Fora

discussionandaknifearecalledmedicalbecausetheformer

proceedsfrommedicalscience,andthelatterisusefultoit。Anda

thingiscalledhealthyinasimilarway;onethingbecauseitis

indicativeofhealth,anotherbecauseitisproductiveofit。And

thesameistrueintheothercases。Everythingthatis,then,issaid

to’be’inthissameway;eachthingthatisissaidto’be’because

itisamodificationofbeingquabeingorapermanentora

transientstateoramovementofit,orsomethingelseofthesort。

Andsinceeverythingthatismaybereferredtosomethingsingleand

common,eachofthecontrarietiesalsomaybereferredtothefirst

differencesandcontrarietiesofbeing,whetherthefirst

differencesofbeingarepluralityandunity,orlikenessand

unlikeness,orsomeotherdifferences;letthesebetakenasalready

discussed。Itmakesnodifferencewhetherthatwhichisbereferredto

beingortounity。Foreveniftheyarenotthesamebutdifferent,at

leasttheyareconvertible;forthatwhichisoneisalsosomehow

being,andthatwhichisbeingisone。

Butsinceeverypairofcontrariesfallstobeexaminedbyoneand

thesamescience,andineachpaironetermistheprivativeofthe

otherthoughonemightregardingsomecontrariesraisethequestion,

howtheycanbeprivatelyrelated,viz。thosewhichhavean

intermediate,e。g。unjustandjust-inallsuchcasesonemustmaintain

thattheprivationisnotofthewholedefinition,butoftheinfima

species。ifthejustmanis’byvirtueofsomepermanentdisposition

obedienttothelaws’,theunjustmanwillnotineverycasehave

thewholedefinitiondeniedofhim,butmaybemerely’insomerespect

deficientinobediencetothelaws’,andinthisrespecttheprivation

willattachtohim;andsimilarlyinallothercases。

Asthemathematicianinvestigatesabstractions(forbefore

beginninghisinvestigationhestripsoffallthesensible

qualities,e。g。weightandlightness,hardnessanditscontrary,and

alsoheatandcoldandtheothersensiblecontrarieties,andleaves

onlythequantitativeandcontinuous,sometimesinone,sometimesin

two,sometimesinthreedimensions,andtheattributesofthesequa

quantitativeandcontinuous,anddoesnotconsidertheminanyother

respect,andexaminestherelativeposi

这是VIP章节,可购买本章或开通会员后阅读
开通会员
字体大小
背景颜色