James Mill

第46章

18。Lecturexxv。ThisquestionastowhetherBrownhadorhadnotgrosslymisrepresentedReidandotherphilosophers,lettoanentangledargument,inwhichMilldefendedBrownagainstHamilton。IwillnotaskwhetherReidwasa’naturalrealist’

ora’cosmotheticidealist,’orwhatDescartesorArnauldthoughtaboutthequestion。

19。Reid’sWorks,p。128。

20。Lectures,pp。

150,158-59。

21。Dissertations,p。98。CompareBrown’sTwenty-fourthLecturewithTracy’sIdé;ologie,ch。vii,andtheaccountofthewayinwhichtheinfantlearnsfromresistancetoinferacause,andmakeofthecauseunê;trequin’estpasmoi。

Theresemblanceiscertainlyclose。BrownwasfamiliarwithFrenchliterature,andshowsitbymanyquotations,thoughhedoesnot,Ithink,refertoTracy。Brown,itmustbenoticed,didnothimselfpublishhislectures,andaprofessorisnotboundtogiveallhissourcesinpopularlectures。

Anexplanationwouldhavebeendueinatreatise。PicavetquotesRhé;toré;’sPhilosophiedeThomasBrown(abookwhichIhavenotseen)forthestatementthatBrown’slecturesoftenreadlikeatranslationofLaromiguiè;re,withwhomBrownwas’perhaps’acquainted。As,however,theLé;ç;ons,towhichreferenceisapparentlymade,didnotappeartill1815and1818,whenBrown’slectureswerealreadywritten,thisseemstobeimpossible。

Thecoincidence,whichtomeseemstobeexaggeratedbythestatement,isexplicablebyacommonrelationtopreviouswriters。

22。Lectures,p。166

(Lect。xxvi)。

23。Lectures,p。158

这是VIP章节,可购买本章或开通会员后阅读
开通会员
字体大小
背景颜色