下载辰思小说免费APP
KingsmighthelpProvidence。AnewTrajanwoulddeservetobecalledthefatherofhispeople,ifheincreasedthemarriage-rate。Malthusrepliesthatthestatisticswhichtheworthymanhimselfproducedshowedconclusivelythatthemarriagesdependeduponthedeaths。Thebirthsfillupthevacancies,andtheprincewhoincreasedthepopulationbeforevacanciesarosewouldsimplyincreasetherateofmortality。60Ifyouwanttoincreaseyourbirth-ratewithoutabsolutelyproducingfamine,asheremarksafterwards,61makeyourtownsunhealthy,andencouragesettlementbymarshes。Youmightthusdoublethemortality,andwemightallmarryprematurelywithoutbeingabsolutelystarved。Hisownaimisnottosecurethegreatestnumberofbirths,buttobesurethatthegreatestnumberofthosebornmaybesupported。62TheingeniousM。Muret,again,hadfoundaSwissparishinwhichthemeanlifewasthehighestandthefecunditysmallestknown。HepiouslyconjecturesthatitmaybealawofGodthat’theforceoflifeineachcountryshouldbeintheinverseratioofitsfecundity。’Heneedsnotbetakehimselftoamiracle,saysMalthus。63Thecaseissimplythatinasmallandhealthyvillage,wherepeoplehadbecomeawareoftheimportanceofthe’preventivecheck,’theyoungpeopleputoffmarriagetilltherewasroomforthem,andconsequentlybothloweredthebirthrateandraisedtheaveragedurationoflife。
Nothing,saysMalthusveryforcibly,hascausedmoreerrorsthantheconfusionbetween’relativeandpositive,andbetweencauseandeffect。’64Heishereansweringtheargumentthatbecausethepoorwhohadcowswerethemostindustrious,thewaytomakethemindustriouswastogivethemcows。Malthusthinksitmoreprobablethatindustrygotthecowthanthatthecowproducedindustry。
Thisisatriflinginstanceofaverygeneraltruth。Peoplehadbeencontenttonoticethedeathscausedbywaranddisease,andtoinferatoncethatwhatcauseddeathmustdiminishpopulation。Malthusshowsthenecessityofobservingothercollateralresults。Thegapmaybemadesogreatastodiminishpopulation;butitmaybecompensatedbyamorerapidreproduction;
or,therapidityofreproductionmayitselfbethecauseofthedisease;
sothattoremoveonekindofmortalitymaybeonsomeoccasiontointroduceothers。Thestreamisdammedononebreachtoflowmorestronglythroughotheroutlets。65
Thisis,Iconceive,tosaysimplythatMalthuswasintroducingareallyscientificmethod。Thefactstakeninthetrueorderbecameatonceintelligibleinsteadofsuggestingmysteriousandirregularinterferences。Earlierwritershadbeencontenttosingleoutoneparticularsetofphenomenawithoutattendingtoitsplaceinthemoregeneralandcomplexprocesses,ofwhichtheyformedanintegralpart。Infanticide,asHumehadpointedout,mighttendtoincreasepopulation。66Inprospect,itmightencouragepeopletohavebabies;andwhenbabiescame,naturalaffectionmightpreventtheactualcarryingoutoftheintention。Tojudgeoftheactualeffect,wehavetoconsiderthewholeoftheconcretecase。Itmaybecarriedout,asapparentlyintheSouthSeaislands,sogenerallyastolimitpopulation;oritmaybe,asinChina,anindicationthatthepressureissogreatthatanumberofinfantsbecomesuperfluous。Itssuppressionmight,intheonecase,leadtoanincreaseofthepopulation;intheother,totheincreaseofotherformsofmortality。Malthus’sinvestigationsillustratethenecessityofreferringeveryparticularprocesstoitsplaceinthewholesystem,ofnotinghowanygivenchangemightsetupasetofactionsandreactionsinvirtueofthegeneralelasticityofpopulation,andthusofconstantlyreferringateverysteptothegeneralconditionsofhumanlife。Hesucceededinmakingmanypointsclear,andofshowinghowhastilymanyinferenceshadbeendrawn。Heexplained,forexample,whytherevolutionarywarshadnotdiminishedthepopulationofFrance,inspiteofthegreatnumberofdeaths,67andthusgaveanexampleofasoundmethodofinquirywhichhasexercisedagreatinfluenceuponlaterobservers。Malthuswasconstantlymisunderstoodandmisrepresented,andhisopponentsoftenallegeasfatalobjectionstohisdoctrinetheveryfactsbywhichitwasreallysupported。Butwemay,Ithink,say,thatsincehiswritingnoseriouseconomicalwriterhasadoptedtheoldhastyguesses,orhasventuredtoproposeatheorywithoutregardtotheprinciplesofwhichhefirstbroughtoutthefullsignificance。
V。POLITICALAPPLICATIO