Democracy In America

第38章

Thisisthenthesubjectonwhichitismostimportantforeachofustoentertainfixedideas;andunhappilyitisalsothesubjectonwhichitismostdifficultforeachofus,lefttohimself,tosettlehisopinionsbythesoleforceofhisreason。

Nonebutmindssingularlyfreefromtheordinaryanxietiesoflife—mindsatoncepenetrating,subtle,andtrainedbythinking—canevenwiththeassistanceofmuchtimeandcare,soundthedepthofthesemostnecessarytruths。And,indeed,weseethatthesephilosophersarethemselvesalmostalwaysenshroudedinuncertainties;thatateverystepthenaturallightwhichilluminatestheirpathgrowsdimmerandlesssecure;andthat,inspiteofalltheirefforts,theyhaveasyetonlydiscoveredasmallnumberofconflictingnotions,onwhichthemindofmanhasbeentossedaboutforthousandsofyears,withouteitherlayingafirmergraspontruth,orfindingnoveltyeveninitserrors。

Studiesofthisnaturearefarabovetheaveragecapacityofmen;

andevenifthemajorityofmankindwerecapableofsuchpursuits,itisevidentthatleisuretocultivatethemwouldstillbewanting。FixedideasofGodandhumannatureareindispensabletothedailypracticeofmen’slives;butthepracticeoftheirlivespreventsthemfromacquiringsuchideas。

Thedifficultyappearstometobewithoutaparallel。

Amongstthesciencestherearesomewhichareusefultothemassofmankind,andwhicharewithinitsreach;otherscanonlybeapproachedbythefew,andarenotcultivatedbythemany,whorequirenothingbeyondtheirmoreremoteapplications:butthedailypracticeofthescienceIspeakofisindispensabletoall,althoughthestudyofitisinaccessibletothefargreaternumber。

GeneralideasrespectingGodandhumannaturearethereforetheideasaboveallotherswhichitismostsuitabletowithdrawfromthehabitualactionofprivatejudgment,andinwhichthereismosttogainandleasttolosebyrecognizingaprincipleofauthority。Thefirstobjectandoneoftheprincipaladvantagesofreligions,istofurnishtoeachofthesefundamentalquestionsasolutionwhichisatonceclear,precise,intelligibletothemassofmankind,andlasting。Therearereligionswhichareveryfalseandveryabsurd;butitmaybeaffirmed,thatanyreligionwhichremainswithinthecircleI

havejusttraced,withoutaspiringtogobeyondit(asmanyreligionshaveattemptedtodo,forthepurposeofenclosingoneverysidethefreeprogressofthehumanmind),imposesasalutaryrestraintontheintellect;anditmustbeadmittedthat,ifitdonotsavemeninanotherworld,suchreligionisatleastveryconducivetotheirhappinessandtheirgreatnessinthis。Thisismoreespeciallytrueofmenlivinginfreecountries。Whenthereligionofapeopleisdestroyed,doubtgetsholdofthehighestportionsoftheintellect,andhalfparalyzesalltherestofitspowers。Everymanaccustomshimselftoentertainnonebutconfusedandchangingnotionsonthesubjectsmostinterestingtohisfellow—creaturesandhimself。Hisopinionsareill—defendedandeasilyabandoned:

and,despairingofeverresolvingbyhimselfthehardestproblemsofthedestinyofman,heignoblysubmitstothinknomoreaboutthem。Suchaconditioncannotbutenervatethesoul,relaxthespringsofthewill,andprepareapeopleforservitude。Nordoesitonlyhappen,insuchacase,thattheyallowtheirfreedomtobewrestedfromthem;theyfrequentlythemselvessurrenderit。Whenthereisnolongeranyprincipleofauthorityinreligionanymorethaninpolitics,menarespeedilyfrightenedattheaspectofthisunboundedindependence。Theconstantagitationofallsurroundingthingsalarmsandexhauststhem。Aseverythingisatseainthesphereoftheintellect,theydetermineatleastthatthemechanismofsocietyshouldbefirmandfixed;andastheycannotresumetheirancientbelief,theyassumeamaster。

Formyownpart,Idoubtwhethermancaneversupportatthesametimecompletereligiousindependenceandentirepublicfreedom。AndIaminclinedtothink,thatiffaithbewantinginhim,hemustserve;andifhebefree,hemustbelieve。

Perhaps,however,thisgreatutilityofreligionsisstillmoreobviousamongstnationswhereequalityofconditionsprevailsthanamongstothers。Itmustbeacknowledgedthatequality,whichbringsgreatbenefitsintotheworld,neverthelesssuggeststomen(aswillbeshownhereafter)someverydangerouspropensities。Ittendstoisolatethemfromeachother,toconcentrateeveryman’sattentionuponhimself;anditlaysopenthesoultoaninordinateloveofmaterialgratification。Thegreatestadvantageofreligionistoinspirediametricallycontraryprinciples。Thereisnoreligionwhichdoesnotplacetheobjectofman’sdesiresaboveandbeyondthetreasuresofearth,andwhichdoesnotnaturallyraisehissoultoregionsfarabovethoseofthesenses。Noristhereanywhichdoesnotimposeonmansomesortofdutiestohiskind,andthusdrawshimattimesfromthecontemplationofhimself。Thisoccursinreligionsthemostfalseanddangerous。Religiousnationsarethereforenaturallystrongontheverypointonwhichdemocraticnationsareweak;whichshowsofwhatimportanceitisformentopreservetheirreligionastheirconditionsbecomemoreequal。

IhaveneithertherightnortheintentionofexaminingthesupernaturalmeanswhichGodemploystoinfusereligiousbeliefintotheheartofman。Iamatthismomentconsideringreligionsinapurelyhumanpointofview:myobjectistoinquirebywhatmeanstheymaymosteasilyretaintheirswayinthedemocraticagesuponwhichweareentering。Ithasbeenshownthat,attimesofgeneralcultivationandequality,thehumanminddoesnotconsenttoadoptdogmaticalopinionswithoutreluctance,andfeelstheirnecessityacutelyinspiritualmattersonly。Thisproves,inthefirstplace,thatatsuchtimesreligionsought,morecautiouslythanatanyother,toconfinethemselveswithintheirownprecincts;forinseekingtoextendtheirpowerbeyondreligiousmatters,theyincurariskofnotbeingbelievedatall。Thecirclewithinwhichtheyseektoboundthehumanintellectoughtthereforetobecarefullytraced,andbeyonditsvergethemindshouldbeleftinentirefreedomtoitsownguidance。MahommedprofessedtoderivefromHeaven,andhehasinsertedintheKoran,notonlyabodyofreligiousdoctrines,butpoliticalmaxims,civilandcriminallaws,andtheoriesofscience。Thegospel,onthecontrary,onlyspeaksofthegeneralrelationsofmentoGodandtoeachother—beyondwhichitinculcatesandimposesnopointoffaith。Thisalone,besidesathousandotherreasons,wouldsufficetoprovethattheformerofthesereligionswillneverlongpredominateinacultivatedanddemocraticage,whilstthelatterisdestinedtoretainitsswayattheseasatallotherperiods。

Butincontinuationofthisbranchofthesubject,Ifindthatinorderforreligionstomaintaintheirauthority,humanlyspeaking,indemocraticages,theymustnotonlyconfinethemselvesstrictlywithinthecircleofspiritualmatters:theirpoweralsodependsverymuchonthenatureofthebelieftheyinculcate,ontheexternalformstheyassume,andontheobligationstheyimpose。Theprecedingobservation,thatequalityleadsmentoverygeneralandveryextensivenotions,isprincipallytobeunderstoodasappliedtothequestionofreligion。MenlivinginasimilarandequalconditionintheworldreadilyconceivetheideaoftheoneGod,governingeverymanbythesamelaws,andgrantingtoeverymanfuturehappinessonthesameconditions。TheideaoftheunityofmankindconstantlyleadsthembacktotheideaoftheunityoftheCreator;whilst,onthecontrary,inastateofsocietywheremenarebrokenupintoveryunequalranks,theyareapttodeviseasmanydeitiesastherearenations,castes,classes,orfamilies,andtotraceathousandprivateroadstoheaven。

ItcannotbedeniedthatChristianityitselfhasfelt,toacertainextent,theinfluencewhichsocialandpoliticalconditionsexerciseonreligiousopinions。AttheepochatwhichtheChristianreligionappeareduponearth,Providence,bywhomtheworldwasdoubtlesspreparedforitscoming,hadgatheredalargeportionofthehumanrace,likeanimmenseflock,underthesceptreoftheCaesars。Themenofwhomthismultitudewascomposedweredistinguishedbynumerousdifferences;buttheyhadthusmuchincommon,thattheyallobeyedthesamelaws,andthateverysubjectwassoweakandinsignificantinrelationtotheimperialpotentate,thatallappearedequalwhentheirconditionwascontrastedwithhis。ThisnovelandpeculiarstateofmankindnecessarilypredisposedmentolistentothegeneraltruthswhichChristianityteaches,andmayservetoexplainthefacilityandrapiditywithwhichtheythenpenetratedintothehumanmind。Thecounterpartofthisstateofthingswasexhibitedafterthedestructionoftheempire。TheRomanworldbeingthenasitwereshatteredintoathousandfragments,eachnationresumeditspristineindividuality。Aninfinitescaleofranksverysoongrewupinthebosomofthesenations;thedifferentracesweremoresharplydefined,andeachnationwasdividedbycastesintoseveralpeoples。Inthemidstofthiscommoneffort,whichseemedtobeurginghumansocietytothegreatestconceivableamountofvoluntarysubdivision,Christianitydidnotlosesightoftheleadinggeneralideaswhichithadbroughtintotheworld。Butitappeared,nevertheless,tolenditself,asmuchaswaspossible,tothosenewtendenciestowhichthefractionaldistributionofmankindhadgivenbirth。MencontinuedtoworshipanonlyGod,theCreatorandPreserverofallthings;buteverypeople,everycity,and,sotospeak,everyman,thoughttoobtainsomedistinctprivilege,andwinthefavorofanespecialpatronatthefootoftheThroneofGrace。UnabletosubdividetheDeity,theymultipliedandimproperlyenhancedtheimportanceofthedivineagents。ThehomageduetosaintsandangelsbecameanalmostidolatrousworshipamongstthemajorityoftheChristianworld;andapprehensionsmightbeentertainedforamomentlestthereligionofChristshouldretrogradetowardsthesuperstitionswhichithadsubdued。Itseemsevident,thatthemorethebarriersareremovedwhichseparatenationfromnationamongstmankind,andcitizenfromcitizenamongstapeople,thestrongeristhebentofthehumanmind,asifbyitsownimpulse,towardstheideaofanonlyandall—powerfulBeing,dispensingequallawsinthesamemannertoeveryman。Indemocraticages,then,itismoreparticularlyimportantnottoallowthehomagepaidtosecondaryagentstobeconfoundedwiththeworshipduetotheCreatoralone。

Anothertruthisnolessclear—thatreligionsoughttoassumefewerexternalobservancesindemocraticperiodsthanatanyothers。InspeakingofphilosophicalmethodamongtheAmericans,Ihaveshownthatnothingismorerepugnanttothehumanmindinanageofequalitythantheideaofsubjectiontoforms。Menlivingatsuchtimesareimpatientoffigures;totheireyessymbolsappeartobethepuerileartificewhichisusedtoconcealortosetofftruths,whichshouldmorenaturallybebaredtothelightofopenday:theyareunmovedbyceremonia

这是VIP章节,可购买本章或开通会员后阅读
开通会员
字体大小
背景颜色